Spectra S2 Vs Medela Pump in Style Breast Pumps

Differences between spectra s2 vs Medela pump in style.

After realizing that you are expecting that bundle of joy, you started doing your research on the best products for your baby as you want the best for him or her. When it comes to expressing milk, maybe you have done your research and narrowed the breast pumps to Spectra or Medela. When it comes to Spectra, we have Spectra s1 and s2 and you can get their differences here. We now want to compare Spectra s2 vs Medela pump in style breast pumps.

We all know that they are among the best breast pumps in the market, but I want you to decide on which one to purchase that will work best for you and your little baby. Let us get into details right away.

In a hurry? Check this!

Comparison Between Spectra S2 Vs Medela Pump in Style

  • Spectra s2 has a closed system unlike in medela which has an open system.
  • Spectra comes with 2 bottles while medela comes with 4 bottles.
  • Medela is more portable than spectra.
  • Medela comes with a cooler while for spectra you purchase separately.
  • Spectra has 2-years warranty while medela has one-year warranty.
  • Medela comes with a tote bag while spectra have no bag.
  • Spectra has a nightlight unlike in medela pump in style.
  • Spectra has 2 sets of 24mm and 28 mm flanges while medela has 1 set of 24mm flanges.
  • Medela is time efficient than spectra s2.
  • Spectra s2 is quieter than medela pump in style.

Similarities in Both Spectra S2 And Medela Pump in Style


  • Are double electric.
  • Are BPA free
  • Have customizable settings

Spectra S2 Breast Pump

Spectra s2 is highly used globally due to its good features. Before anything else, let me first explain to you the features of this super cute with soft pink color breast pump.


Spectra s2 is considered as hygienic due to its closed system. What does closed system mean? This means that there is no need of cleaning the narrow tubing. The closed system ensures that the tubing is ever dry by preventing air flow between expressed milk and the pump tubing. This protects the expressed milk from bacteria and viruses.

Customizable settings

When expressing milk, as the mum, you can adjust the settings depending on your flow or body’s response. This is enabled by the adjustable suction and the 2-phase cycling which is the let-down and expression mode.

Material used

Spectra s2 is safe to use as it is made of materials that are free of harmful BPA and DEHP. Not only the breast pump that is safe, but also all spectra containers that comes in to contact with the baby’s milk.


Another great advantage that we love about this breast pump is because it is light in weight. With only 3.3 pounds, you can carry it anywhere in the house.

Pump capability

Whether you want single or double pumping, spectra s2 will sort you as it is capable of both.


Late night diaper changes can be hectic. But with spectra s2 you will be sorted as it has a night light that will ensure you breastfeed or change diapers conveniently. Instead of lighting the bulb which can irritate your baby’s eyes, just use the spectra’s nightlight.


Spectra s2 breast pump does not need batteries to operate.

Additional features

  • It is hospital grade
  • Has detachable power cord
  •  2 spectra wide neck bottle.
  • 2 sets of 28mm flanges
  • 2 sets of 24mm flanges
  • 2 spectra duckbill valve
  • 2 spectra backflow protector.

Medela Pump in Style Breast Pump


Medela pump in style is well made with a patented and research based 2-phase expression technology which makes mothers to produce more milk in less time. It’s one of the best with maximized flow.

Customizable settings

The single knob can be adjusted to the speed of your choice. The set of 24mm flanges allows you to enhance the expressing experience based on what is comfortable to you.


With only 0.248 ounces I’m sure you will carry it anywhere you go as long as you want to express milk. What makes it even more exciting is the fact that it comes with a tote bag which is equipped with a removable cooler bag and a portable battery pack. This will make it easy for you to carry it anywhere you want to go.

Overflow protection

Medela pump in style has a closed system at the motor. This ensures that no milk enters the motor.

Pump capability

It can be used as both single or double pump.

Materials used

Medela breast pump is safe for your baby as all parts that touch the milk are free of BPA.

Additional features

  • Battery pack
  • A tote bag
  • Cooler bag and ice pack
  • 1 set of 24mm flanges
  • 2 connectors
  • 1 set of tubing
  • 4 5oz bottles with lids


Maybe you can now ask: Spectra s2 vs Medela pump in style, what works better than the other? Well, all works pretty well, almost the same but, if you want something to go to work with after giving birth, you can opt for spectra s2. This is because it is more quiet hence you won’t bother your colleagues.

On the other hand, if you want a pump that is time efficient, you can opt for medela pump in style. It pumps much faster than spectra s2. Even though spectra s2 comes with 2 bottles, getting 4 bottles from medela can also be a plus when you purchase medela pump in style hence saving you some coins.

Otherwise, both of these pumps are good quality!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top